For a moment Inigo looks kind of speechless, but then he frowns and just.. tries. That's all he can do right now, isn't it.

"Listen. I don't care if you're an evil or a good god." Okay, no, he does care! But it's just not as important for this thing right now! "I just.. Is there anything at all I can do to convince you to not completely uproot the local population's idea of the world by riding around in this?"