"I've never seen anything like this before.."

So how is she supposed to tell what's out of place? If you'd ask Madoka, she would say that all of them are what's out of place right now, but she knows that voice can't have meant that.

"Maybe it's something like those animals on the outside.. Those really didn't feel like they belonged. I mean--! Of course there's usually birds in a tree, but I've never see any fire lasers from their eyes!"